Is a new warranty motor a selling feature?
 

Hi, I just wanted some advice for my carsales ad, I am selling my 2009 STI hatch and i didn't know whether to state that my engine was replaced under subaru warranty in 2010 with the nitrided crank version. would people shy away from a car that has had a new motor put in or would they see it as a bonus?

cheers

50/50 depends on the person, some would see a new motor while others see a thrashed car that died (even if it was just a failure!)

Personally i wouldn't care either way!

I would put it on my ad if it was me.
It eliminates the tyre kickers in a way. But obviously you gotta state a valid reason for the failure of the old engine.

It depends on the person who reads the advertisement.
For me It wouldn't set off alarm bells, but it would warrant further investigation as to why the motor was replaced.

If the motor was replaced due to a faulty component, then I don't see an issue to that at all, but if the motor was replaced due to a bad aftermarket tune, then I would be cautious to proceed any further.

Personally, if I was searching carsales and saw that it had a replaced motor, I wouldn't bother.

To me I would think either its been thrashed and what else is screwed on it or it is a lemon and will be troublesome.

Don't mention the engine at all in the advert, only when they inspect it.

Just mention it has the Upgraded Nitrated crank and not about it having a new engine. :icon_thum

If they're serious and come look at the car explain the situation when they rock up.

[QUOTE=apg39;556440]Don't mention the engine at all in the advert, only when they inspect it.[/QUOTE]

No way. Don't waste people's time; they deserve to know from the outset. If I rocked up to look at the car and then the owner said "oh by the way, the engine had to be replaced" I'd become sus ("why didn't he mention this is in the first place?") and I'd probably be vary wary and possibly untrusting of whatever the owner has/will say about the car.

As said, if you mention that there is an upgraded Nitraded crank in a new engine (is there actually a legit reason, by the way?) the worst you will do is turn off the tyre-kickers...

The engine and tune has always been stock but my engine suffered ring landing failure and subsequent oil use issues which lead to engine failure. Subaru didn't question the warranty claim and they replaced the whole motor last year. not sure how i should put it in my ad?

Engine was recalled due to a faulty batch of piston rings and a new engine installed free of charge by Subaru Australia :D

I'd also note the km traveled on the car before the engine was replaced.

[QUOTE=Soksta;556461]Engine was recalled due to a faulty batch of piston rings and a new engine installed free of charge by Subaru Australia :D

I'd also note the km traveled on the car before the engine was replaced.[/QUOTE]

thats quite a good way to put it.
It seems the general consensus is for me to include the warranty motor change in the ad...

Mention it, the dealer who did it and the extended warranty from it.

Anyone investigating will notice the engine number had been changed.

it should also be in the logbook.

Don't mention it.. It was fixed under warranty, not for any issue other than the original being faulty.

[QUOTE=obiwun32;556362]Hi, I just wanted some advice for my carsales ad, I am selling my 2009 STI hatch and i didn't know whether to state that my engine was replaced under subaru warranty in 2010 with the nitrided crank version. would people shy away from a car that has had a new motor put in or would they see it as a bonus?

cheers[/QUOTE]

Can you please explain the difference between the stock EJ257 and the engine provided by Subaru under warranty? thks

Has the engine number been changed on the registration and by subaru database?

[QUOTE=Bruce;556686]Can you please explain the difference between the stock EJ257 and the engine provided by Subaru under warranty? thks[/QUOTE]

All 2010 Sti's have a nitrided crank. City Subaru were sent a motor from subaru aus and it was the latest 2010 motor.

the engine number had to be changed with licensing department and subaru would have the new number in their records. City subaru didn't make any note of the change in my service manual, they said just to bring it in when the next service is due like normal.

How many kms on the og motor?

If its say 10,000kms as an example I reckon they should provide some kind of note in the logbook as it won't be at the actual kms on the new engine for the servicing schedule.