I just signed on to Just car for my 07 STI and im paying 1800$ a year, insuring my car for 53000$ and im only 21......
I also had my 06 XR8 which i bought new for 51000$ and insured for 54000$ with just car and made a claim and had no problems what so ever, was a front panel, side indicator, front bumper drivers side headlight, rim and tyre, and fog light...... from when i did the claim i was sent off to get 2 quotes from my choice of THERE workshops and then 1 from my choice of workshops, they ended up choosing there own, but was booked in within couple days fixed and got it back within 3 days so was basically a week to get it back from when it was hit.......
So i have nothing against them.... and i think 1800$ for a 07 STI insured for 53000$ with a 21yr old driver is pretty good.