Your view on the impending execution of Nguyen in Singapore - Page 3 - Perth-WRX.com

chee · #21 23-11-2005, 11:51 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by EvilCabbage

Er.. what business is it of ours in the first place?

If they tried telling us how to run our 'justice' system, we'd swiftly tell them to get screwed, right? How is this any different?

its our right to prevent the death of people. killing is fucked anyways. dying is the easy way out. lock him up.

so in the end, i am against capital punishment.

BLUES · #22 23-11-2005, 12:08 PM

hanging's a bit rough - go the bullet instead.

scoobysix · #23 23-11-2005, 12:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chee

dying is the easy way out. lock him up.

I think it's meant to be a deterrent as well as a punishment. Capital punishment sends out very strong warnings to would-be offenders, and what better cure than prevention?

In any case, whether by bullet or by the gallows, death is supposed to be instantaneous. The rope length is calculated according to the person's body weight.

EvilCabbage · #24 23-11-2005, 12:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by chee

its our right to prevent the death of people.

I must have missed that part of international diplomacy 101.

Please explain to me why we have any place telling these people how to run their country, especially when the argument is sparked by a single person who's been convicted of trafficing narcotics?

scoobysix · #25 23-11-2005, 01:08 PM

Just as a side note, lest anyone thinks the pendulum only swings to one side, there were a couple of Singaporeans that were recently caught and convicted of drug smuggling overseas, currently sitting on death row (I think in Vietnam or Cambodia, can't remember). The point is, the Singaporean media isn't kicking up a storm over it, neither is the Government. Fact remains that they have been caught, tried and found guilty of their crime in a fair court of law. Any appeals have been through the right channels, and it's just too bad if they are unsuccessful.

e-rex-shon · #26 23-11-2005, 01:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mat

Sooner we get rid of both the users and dealers of hard drugs the better IMHO.

I'd like to know your definition of "Hard Drugs". Where do you draw the line mate??

chee · #27 23-11-2005, 01:12 PM

we're giving them constructive criticism. fuck i dont care if we're telling someone how to run their country. im saying capital punishment is fucked. as fellow human beings we have the right to say killing is wrong. heard of human rights?

LegacyGT · #28 23-11-2005, 01:22 PM

capital punishment is right!

seperates the men from the boys from the idiots.

with pain there is respect. if we had capital punishment here u think the kids here today would be such turds?

jEstEr? · #29 23-11-2005, 01:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by fobz

I agree that we you do the crime, take the punishment. However, consider this:

If you get the death penalty for carrying drugs, then why not go down in style
by caught by killing a few cops (or civillians) in the arrest/struggle etc.... They
can't kill you twice (1st for drugs, 2nd for murder). That way the cops will be
more worried about arresting a drug dealer simply because they themselves
become a target.

Thats a rediculously stupid answer, congrats. Not only are you bringing more misery to the world with the drugs you are moving, but your also trying to make a few widows while your at it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by scoobysix

In any case, whether by bullet or by the gallows, death is supposed to be instantaneous. The rope length is calculated according to the person's body weight.

yeah, generally the knot is on the side of the head, so their is a decent fall and your neck snaps, not the old style hanging where you fell half a meter and did the 'dance' while you asphixiated.

To the people saying the death penalty is wrong, fair call. But why isnt the australian govt lobying the singa's govt to stop *all* hangings, what makes this one persons life more important than any other? was he a brain surgeon or missionary worker? Its a bit hypocritical that his life is more important because he holds an australian passport.

jEstEr? · #30 23-11-2005, 01:27 PM

ps, there was some shit also brought up recently about it being bad to beat children... i reckon children need more of a beating these days than anything.