Yeah I spent 5 months in a hydro pool in 09 - couldnt walk out of the pool without crutches and brace, in pool was fine.

__________________
I am only an asshole on the internet :)

[SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]

I had a patella re-alignment & scrape on my left knee about 10 years ago and recently had similar feelings as you described in same knee, so I tried altering my running tecnique, (the angle and flow your foot hits the treadly) made a big difference, however, now I am getting sever shin splints in my lower right leg.. Can't win..

But as others have pointed out, cross trainer + spin bike are way to go.. Vary speeds and resistance to build your lungs & heart musles will also help to build your stamina..

Zero to Hero takes time.... Just keep focued on the end game..
And well done TJ, blood & sweat sounds like its paying off..

By the sounds of it we should start a PWRX biggest loser!!! Few of us have a few (10-15) kg's we'd like to lose!!!

Running on a treadmill will place large amounts of stress on yours legs due to the resistance giving that jarring effect on the leg muscles so as suggested i would try to avoid it until a time that your confident you knee pain has dissipated. As for the knee pain itself it could be several things but most common cause are poor running technique or inversion/eversion of the foot whilst running ... do you where orthodics ? could also be imbalances of the upper leg muscles surrounding the knee which is common in a lot of runners basically your vastus lateralis (the muscle on the outside of the leg) can tend to be stronger than the vastus medialis muscle (on the inside of the leg) which in effect can cause patella alignment issues of the knee and place additional strain on the ligaments causing pain according to the weaker side of the leg.

Either way i would run it past a physio and try get ontop of the pain side of your running straight away cause knees are horrible joints for injury and can lead to long term effects mate !

This is what I have

Put your leg out straight on the floor sitting up and contract your quads - if your knee cap moves up and across to the outside you probably have this issue and need to strengthen the inside muscle if the knee cap goes stright up and down then not that issue.
Either way I would go and see a good sports physio to get them to have a look at it

__________________
RS RA
The more people I meet the more I like my Dog!

12.463 1/4 mile, not bad for an old school Liberty [DECEASED]

MY08 Liberty Tuned by STi

^^^ Good tip. I like objective little diagnostic techniques.

__________________
Rotor of Fail
Ducati 998s
Ducati Streetfighter S
496 CI Injected Big Block. Carbon positive???

It goes to the right.

urghh

I've had patella alignment issues...it hurts and sucks. Go see a physio and get a really knowledgable personal trainer. All can be fixed but get on it early.

My issues stemmed from a the tight muscles down the outside of my thigh and a poor running technique (I didn't engage my glutes enough). Bear in mind I only weigh 73-77kg's and compete in endurance running/cycling...so it can happen even when your body is somewhat conditioned to fitness.